Jan
19

The Battle of the Short URL Services

Short URL addresses have changed the way we share links on the internet. Short URLs have their advantages and disadvantages. An advantage is having a link that is easier to share so that more people will remember the link and less of a chance of it being wrongly written. A Short URL can also be useful if you have a limited space to write, for example, in Twitter where the limit is 140 characters. Also, in an email, a short URL isn’t as error prone to having breaks in it than a longer URL.

However there are also disadvantages for short URLs, since you cannot see the end link of a short URL, you can be led to spam or shock sites. However their are solutions to this problem, having a preview link, so that the user knows the end link. Another problem is that if the URL service crashes then all the links registered with that service don’t work.

In this blog post I’ll be outlining my favourite and the most common short URL services and deciding which is the best.

TinyURL

Probably the most common truncator service around. TinyURL has common features such as an easily remembered domain, fairly short URLs, preview link, custom alias and a bookmarklet. TinyURL says it has around 154 million URLs in its database, this doesn’t allow them to have the shortest link (6 characters).

TinyURL is also prone to crashing, since it is the post popular service on the web it receives over 1.5 billion hits a month, this can lead it to get overloaded and crash, meaning your links don’t work.

There are also many features that TinyURL does not have, such as statistics on your URL, being able to register account to keep track of your links and choosing whether a URL is public or private but overall it does the job well.

is.gd

The main drawing card to is.gd is that it creates one of the shortest links. is.gd can create a URL that is only 7 characters (including punctuation). However like TinyURL is.gd lacks a few features, customisation, stats etc.

One feature of is.gd I really like is their bookmarklet for Firefox. This is a little button that sits in the Firefox toolbar, click it and it automatically shortens the link of the page that you are currently on and copies the new shortened link to the clipboard. So with one click you have your short URL ready to be pasted anywhere.

bit.ly

This shortener service boasts features that most sites don’t have. You can to sign up to an account so that you can track all your links, view information for each link, number of clicks etc. It also has common features such as a bookmarklet, easily remembered name and an option for a custom alias.

I really like this service as it combines features and simplicity equally so that the user can have the best experience.

Google Short Links

This is my favourite service and the one I use most often. What I love about Google Short Links is the ability to have your domain in the URL. For example instead of the short URL being tinyurl.com/1234 it is instead ant.geek.nz/1234. This is great for me because when someone sees the short URL they are curious and visit the parent URL (ant.geek.nz) which generates traffic for this blog! Great huh? Other than this Google Short Links has other great features such as statistics for each link, a bookmarklet and an option whether to make the link private or public.

This service is available with Google Labs for Google Apps.

Lenks

Developed and coded by Rowan, Lenks offers features that no other short URL services offer. For example, huge customisation options when you sign up and the ability to put your links in various folders, humour, informational etc. Lenks also gives you the ability to view other Lenk user links via their profile. With AJAX fast speed Lenks is definitely a short URL service to start using.

Of course Lenks has features common to all short URL services. Overall I highly recommend this service!

The Winner

My favourite short URL service is Google Short Links. I love this service as it is used by only me on my domain. It may not have as many features as other services but the features it does have majorly outweigh the features that are missing. Since this is a Google Labs project we can expect to see many more features to come.

Runnerups are Lenks and is.gd. What I love about Lenks is that it is feature rich. It has a lot of features that most truncate services don’t have. Lenks is still in beta so we can expect to see more great things. On the other side is is.gd, a very simple URL truncator, the stand out feature for me is the one click URL shortener feature, this makes it so easy to post a short link. I hope that other services take after is.gd in this regard.

So there we have it! Of course I only reviewed a sample of short URL services, there are many more avaliable for you to test out!

Have fun linking!

Enjoyed reading this post? If you want more you can subscribe to my RSS feed. Subscribe by email. Or if you want to know what I’m doing you can follow me on Twitter.

9 Comments

Make A Comment
  • JamesNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Mac OS X Mozilla Firefox 3.0.5 Said:

    Excellent post! I always wondered about your flashy your-domain based urls! Will definitely check that out :D

    Another couple worth mention are http://tr.im – good stats, user accounts, custom URLs, very short length. And I just love the nature of tr.im ;) However, it has been known to be flaky – having said that I haven’t experienced before.

    And http://krunchd.com – a new one, but they allow you to collapse a number of URLs into one URL for distribution. Then allow you to edit it into the future. Example: http://krunchd.com/pspress – New service so still a little buggy :D

  • AnthonyNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Windows Vista Mozilla Firefox 3.0.5 Said:

    Thanks for the comment! Am glad you enjoyed the blog post. tr.im looks very promising and will definitely check it out. The problem with having your own domain in your short URL is you have to have a short domain and there aren’t a huge number left. krunchd looks also very interesting, I like the unique idea!

  • BenNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Windows NT Mozilla Firefox 3.0.1 Said:

    Another vote for http://tr.im

    I had a problem a few days back with it giving 501 errors, but apart from that the site is really easy to use and the stats are great.

    Nice Firefox plugin too.

  • AnthonyNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Windows Vista Mozilla Firefox 3.0.5 Said:

    I have just given http://tr.im a go and it looks great, a nice mix of style, features and simplicity. These short URL services seem to be popping up everywhere! :)

  • JamesNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Mac OS X Mozilla Firefox 3.0.5 Said:

    Good point about the short URL… I started going down the path and realised that for pocketsmith.com :/

    But perhaps (when I get into gear on the personal front) I could pull some of these tricks with wigsgiw.com :)

    It is an area that seems to have a little bit of space in it; and considering the relative domination of TinyURL for such a (relatively speaking) long time despite a dearth of features – I think a few stand-outs could present themselves over the coming months / years.

    Personally, I think that the core feature of krunchd places it in a slightly different space than what the stats and graphs do (although the # of clicks to tr.im URLs is interesting from a distribution point of view when used in combination with twitter).

    For example, I would use Krunchd alongside other services like tr.im – depending on the purpose of the url shortening – to direct at a specific URL (tr.im) or a group of resources (krunchd)

  • AnthonyNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Windows Vista Mozilla Firefox 3.0.5 Said:

    Hehe, yeah, you do know that short URLs are supposed to be SHORT! :)

    TinyURL definitely has the dominance out of all the services, which is a pity considering the ease of use, style and feature rich content of other sites. I think that bit.ly, is.gd and tr.im are gaining up on TinyURL, we just have to wait and see though.

    Ah, I see what you’re meaning about krunchd, my worries are that since it is quite a “tricky” idea to grab hold of, a lot of users will be turned off and therefore just resort to TinyURL.

    I’m confident that TinyURL will lose it’s lead in the coming months/years ahead. We will just have to wait and see!

  • Andrew HedgesNo Gravatar NEW ZEALAND Mac OS X Safari 525.27.1 Said:

    My URL-shortening service of choice is also tr.im. I liked it enough to build a Dashboard widget against their API: http://tr.im/trimit

  • Tom - StandOutBlogger.comNo Gravatar AUSTRALIA Windows XP Mozilla Firefox 3.0.8 Said:

    I usually use TinyURL but Google Short Links looks fantastic, so I might have to give it a go :D

  • DNS ToolsNo Gravatar UNITED KINGDOM Windows NT Internet Explorer 8.0 Said:

    This is so cool, I had no idea there were so many of these services out there! Especially that google were doing it!

Comments RSS Feed   TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

top